They asked her to serve coffee: Sexual harassment?
July 16, 2008 by Sam NarisiPosted in: Harassment, In this week's e-newsletter, Latest News & Views, Recent Decisions
Companies are often hit with harassment and discrimination suits because supervisors unintentionally make decisions based on out-dated gender or racial stereotypes.
In one recent case, a woman sued after she was fired from her secretarial job. One of her duties was to bring coffee to the managers in the office. She refused to do it. Because of that, and other performance and attitude issues, she was terminated.
She sued, claiming that asking her to serve coffee was a “reinforcement of an out-dated gender stereotype” — and therefore, sexual harassment.
The company argued that it was part of her job and both male and female employees in the same position had to do it.
The court agreed and threw the case out. Since both genders were treated equally, there was no sexual harassment.
Cite: Klopfenstein v. National Sales and Supply, LLC
Tags: coffee, gender stereotypes, job duties, Klopfenstein, sexual harassment

July 16th, 2008 at 9:27 am
I wonder if she was able to look at a job description before accepting the offer? Even if not, you’d think she would have asked about or the interviewer would have volunteered basic job duties. I wouldn’t want coffee service to be a mandatory part of my job either, but I think I’d be darn sure of the job requirements before I accepted the position. If bringing around coffee in the morning is a bona fide part of the job and she accepted that job, she should have to bring the coffee.