HRLegalNews.com » High Court makes 401(k)s fair game for lawsuits

High Court makes 401(k)s fair game for lawsuits

March 24, 2008 by Sam Narisi
Posted in: Benefits Law, Latest News & Views, Recent Decisions

Heads up for HR: The Supreme Court has just given individual employees the green light to sue to recover losses in their 401(k) accounts.

Heres what happened: An employee in Houston had money in a 401(k) plan sponsored and administered by his employer. He asked the administrator to transfer the money from one mutual fund to another. The request was never honored, and as a result the man missed out on a $150,000 profit. He sued the company to recover the losses.

Two lower courts decided in favor of the company, ruling that the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) only allows lawsuits on behalf of the plan as a whole, not on behalf of individual plan members. But the High Court broke with the established case law and ruled for the employee.

The reason? The way retirement funds are saved has changed a lot since ERISA was passed in 1974. Back then, a lot of companies offered pensions, and doled out money to retirees from one investment fund.

These days, most people put money in 401(k)s or other defined contribution plans. So employees have their own individual accounts, and can lose a lot of money individually, regardless how other people in the plan are doing.

So the Court said it was only logical to let individuals sue to recover those losses.

Cite: LaRue v. DeWolff, Boberg & Associates

Share/Save/Bookmark

2 Responses to “High Court makes 401(k)s fair game for lawsuits”

  1. Pam Carlsen Says:

    How could this happen? Our employees have control over their own accounts. I am the administrator and I would never do this for an employee; I tell them that anything they need done with their account should be done by them because once it is set up it is their personal account.

  2. Jim Grieger Says:

    If the plan does not have or the participant chooses Not to use toll free # or internet access the only resolve is paper changes. If the employer or administrator did not process the change …………there you have it. There are employees/participants that do not have internet access. No Library card.

Leave a Reply


advertisement


advertisement